You won't be called a hater, you will be called ignorant beyond comprehension. GSP has enjoyed a reach advantage on many of his opponents but he isn't a HUGE WW. Anderson on the other hand can comfortably fight at LHW and while he isn't the largest LHW, he is still a good sized one. GSP would struggle to get into fighting shape and step on the scale anywhere near 185 since he walks around at not much more than that but Anderson still has to lose weight to be able to fight at 205.
Anderson would have a significant weight advantage as well as 4 inches of height and I can't find an accurate statistic but it would seem reasonable to assume Silva would have a nice reach advantage as well. So you are comparing GSP being a decent size guy in his division and him probably being one of, if not the smallest MW in the UFC? So his size advantage of his opponents in the same weight class is comparable to the size disadvantage he would have facing Silva?
This is why you and Oli get labeled "haters". It has nothing to do with you disliking GSP but more to do with your delusional shit talk. Now would you fully support this argument if it was made about Anderson and Jon Jones? At least most people are consistent, I think it would be equally unfair to expect Anderson to fight Jones as it would GSP to fight Anderson or Henderson to fight GSP....
.............